Toilet Paper Price Per Sq Ft breakdown: 1 Ply Thin $0.0045 per sq ft (Scott 1000, Marcal 1000) 1 Ply Thick $0.0085 per sq ft (Charmin Basic, Scott Extra Soft, Cottonelle Clean Care & Gentle Care) 2 Ply Thin $0.01 per sq ft (Angel Soft, 7th Generation, Up & Up, White Cloud, Charmin Ultra Strong)Click to see full answer. Similarly, it is asked, who has the best price on toilet paper? The Best Toilet Paper White Cloud Ultra Soft & Thick Toilet Paper Rolls. The Walmart-exclusive brand boasts three-ply sheets priced at 52 cents per roll, coming out to only . Angel Soft Toilet Paper. Quilted Northern Ultra Plush. White Cloud GreenEarth. Likewise, is Scott toilet paper good? Good Housekeeping’s testers considered Scott 1000 to be among the rougher toilet papers they tested, but they also noted that the sheets are thicker than some two-plies. Plus, Scott 1000 dissolved quickly and easily while maintaining strength while wet. Consequently, what is a good price on toilet paper? The most I will pay for toilet paper is 25 cents per roll. So for a 12-pack roll of toilet paper, $3 is a good price. For a 24-pack. $6 is a good price.How much does the average person spend on toilet paper per year?The average American uses 57 squares a day and 50 pounds of toilet paper per year.